Broken Egg

As I’m trying to fry some eggs over-easy, a yolk breaks, and I yell: GODDAMNIT.

Anger of this sort—seemingly out of proportion to the situation—is a habitual affect of my own daily life, embedded in my body since childhood, growing up in a working-class rural white family where violent outbursts were constant…

There is already a certain literature which establishes how lower-class whites have a tendency to be “ornery” and thin-skinned…

I wonder how much of this kind of anger comes from my sense of entitlement—from a racist or sexist belief that eggs should be served to me perfectly, without any effort on my part, that the breaking of a yolk represents a slight against my status?

From a young age—I think like 8 or 10?—it fell to do me to do most of the cooking and cleaning for my parents and little sister. Usually I came home from school to find a list of instructions (fry this hamburger in a pan, boil water in this pot). When my parents came home from work, later, I set the table and served them. During dinner usually there were wild screaming matches and bizarre fights… total chaos and fear… I cleaned the table and washed the dishes… while my father continued to eat and eat and meanwhile to make cruel remarks about how I was a “sissy” and was “doing the women’s work.”

Actually tho one of my happier memories is my grandmother teaching me to crack eggs, and on my first try, an egg broke onto the floor… She smiled and found a towel and said that’s ok, honey, and handed me another egg to try again…

But I think what I mean to say is that somehow projected onto me and ingrained into me was a conflict around doing these chores, a sense that they are shameful for white men to do… a sense that rage always accompanied cooking and eating…

It could be that this morning I had intended to only cook some scrambled eggs but then my sweetheart requested eggs over-easy and it was to me somewhat stressful to cook two dishes and I do not feel confident with my eggs over-easy… I remember my mother often screaming that she was not a short-order cook and that she did not take any special requests… But if she happened to break an egg yolk, she always served that to herself, this was also a rule… that the cook would have to eat whatever was not prepared perfectly, that the perfectly prepared food was reserved for the man of the house…

I could see a chapter developing around this that folds in, for example, how in our town many people (e.g. my father) did not eat onions, garlic, peppers, because they considered this ethnic food, not suitable for white men, who ate (they said) “meat and potatoes.”

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Broken Egg

United in Anger

Larry Kramer’s famous anger…

Sarah Schulman’s discussion of white privilege’s complicated role in the work of ACT UP…

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on United in Anger

Apologetics for White Anger

One of the things I’m curious about is WHITE RAGE APOLOGETICS…

Or, the cultural work that is done in order to justify away working-class white resentment…

Examples like

  • David Brooks recently blaming higher-ed & deindustrialization…
  • Bernie Sanders, from another vantage, claiming that the Democratic party doesn’t support working people and has driven working-class whites into Trump’s hands
  • or Obama famously saying:

You go into these small towns in Pennsylvania and, like a lot of small towns in the Midwest, the jobs have been gone now for 25 years and nothing’s replaced them. And they fell through the Clinton administration, and the Bush administration, and each successive administration has said that somehow these communities are gonna regenerate and they have not. And it’s not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy toward people who aren’t like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.

  • James Baldwin in “Nothing Personal” making the (positively awful) claim that “The poor white was enslaved almost from the instant he arrived on these shores, and he is still enslaved by a brutal and cynical oligarchy.”

In other words, this persistent cultural tendency to suggest that white resentment is a RATIONAL psychological response to objectively difficult socio-economic conditions…

 

I think it is a legitimately interesting question, Why is white affect so resentful, why are whites so prone to rage and bitterness? But this approach—blaming it on a legit grievance—seems to me not to really address the pathological and fascist dimensions of white bitterness…

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Apologetics for White Anger

White Resentment

This blog is for me to take notes about

the fascism of rural white U.S. culture

and white anger/resentment/bitterness

For my next book, I’m thinking about writing a first-hand analysis of rural white fascism…

based on my upbringing in Appalachian Pennsylvania where as a kid I was taught to burn books and shoot guns, and indoctrinated into bigotry and hatred…

As part of my own recovery from that, I’ve decided that, whenever I feel intense episodes of anger/resentment/bitterness, I will make a blog post to try to process/theorize white anger… to begin drafting a study of the white resentment that gives rise to fascism… the resentment that has driven the rise of Trump and Brexit…

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on White Resentment